Bay Shore Insurance Agency email list
Bay Shore, NY has 31 insurance agency in the MapLeads maps index. Use the table below to filter the market, then scrape or export inside MapLeads for full contacts.
Bay Shore Insurance Agency market size
The 31 figure is a deduplicated count for insurance agency in Bay Shore. 65% website coverage means that share of rows has a website or domain. Figures update when MapLeads refreshes the index.
Businesses
31
Insurance Agency in Bay Shore — same business-row filter as the table.
Website coverage
65%
Share of rows in the current filter with a website field (row aggregate).
Reachable pool
20
Rows in this filter with a website field — enrichment pool.
Outreach score
51
0–100 from current-filter volume and website coverage (query-time on rows).
Outreach calculator
Bay Shore insurance agency — start from the 20 operators with a website field (31 total in this cut). Adjust your average order value and close rate to size pipeline.
Formula: reachable pool (rows with a website field) × close rate × average order value. This is a planning estimate, not a forecast — actual conversion depends on offer, list quality, and follow-up.
| Business | Industry | Location | Phone | Website |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Anthony Machiano: Allstate Insurance | Insurance agency; Aut* | Bay Shore, NY | +1 631 *** **26 | allstate.com |
| Michael S. Stagnitta - State Farm I* | Insurance agency; Aut* | Bay Shore, NY | +1 631 *** **50 | michaelsthere.com |
| Briana Ray: Allstate Insurance | Insurance agency; Aut* | Bay Shore, NY | +1 631 *** **00 | allstate.com |
| C Walsh Agency | Insurance agency | Bay Shore, NY | +1 631 *** **50 | cwalshagency.com |
| Robert W McLear Agency Inc | Auto insurance agency* | Bay Shore, NY | +1 631 *** **96 | mclearagency.com |
| Jay Tee Insurance | Insurance agency | Bay Shore, NY | +1 631 *** **00 | jayteeinsurance.com |
| Bill Dunn - State Farm Insurance Ag* | Insurance agency; Aut* | Bay Shore, NY | +1 631 *** **69 | billdunnsf.com |
| ICR Professional Services Inc | Insurance agency | Bay Shore, NY | +1 631 *** **55 | icrprofessionalservic* |
| Douglas Cortez - State Farm Insuran* | Insurance agency; Aut* | Bay Shore, NY | +1 631 *** **03 | douglasmyagent.com |
| Universal Insurance Co | Insurance agency | Bay Shore, NY | +1 315 *** **97 | — |
| AllSafe Insurance Agency | Insurance agency | Bay Shore, NY | +1 631 *** **73 | — |
| Cochrane Insurance | Insurance agency | Bay Shore, NY | +1 631 *** **00 | — |
| Fidelis Care - Bay Shore Community * | Health insurance agen* | Bay Shore, NY | +1 631 *** **96 | fideliscare.org |
| Terry Gibson Insurance Inc | Auto insurance agency* | Bay Shore, NY | +1 631 *** **00 | — |
| All Island Insurance Brokerage LLC | Insurance agency | Bay Shore, NY | +1 631 *** **71 | — |
| J.D.A. Hurley Inc Insurance Agency | Insurance agency | Bay Shore, NY | +1 631 *** **60 | jdahurley.com |
| Oxford Millin Insurance Agency Ltd | Insurance agency | Bay Shore, NY | +1 631 *** **66 | oxfordins.com |
| SASSI Property Coverages | Insurance agency | Bay Shore, NY | +1 631 *** **50 | sassiagency.com |
| Robert Beegel-Allstate Agent | Insurance agency | Bay Shore, NY | +1 631 *** **00 | — |
| Advantage Insurance Brokers, Inc. | Insurance broker; Ins* | Bay Shore, NY | +1 516 *** **18 | aib-agency.com |
Page 1 of 2 · 31 rows
Pull a live list for insurance agency in Bay Shore
MapLeads extracts local businesses from Google Maps, Apple Maps, and Bing Maps— or delivers a ready email list pack when you want a file without running a job. Start a trial, run a real search, and export to CSV the same day.
Insurance Agency in Bay Shore
Bay Shore, NY has 31 insurance agency businesses in the MapLeads maps index, making insurance agency the 11th largest vertical in the city (1.4% of Bay Shore's 2,165 businesses).
64.5% of those insurance agency rows carry a website — the enrichment pool for an email campaign in Bay Shore. Counts refresh with each index update.
The insurance agency market
Captive agencies tied to a single carrier (State Farm, Allstate, Farmers) sit alongside independent agencies that shop policies across multiple carriers, and the two operate under very different incentive structures. The agency principal — often the founding agent — makes the call on staffing, office software, and marketing spend. Independent agencies in particular are constantly recruited by carriers looking to add distribution.
Bay Shore holds 0.0% of the 188,072 insurance agency businesses MapLeads tracks nationwide; within NY, Brooklyn leads the vertical at 354.
Bay Shore as a market
Bay Shore overall holds 2,165 businesses. Its largest verticals are Restaurant (153), Contractor (111), Medical Clinic (72) — insurance agency sits further down the mix at 11th.
How to use this list
- Start with the 31 Bay Shore insurance agency rows below, then expand to nearby cities if volume runs short.
- Prefer rows with a website (64.5% of this market) for enrichment before cold email.
- Re-pull this city × industry cut after campaigns or quarterly — not the full national file every time.
FAQ: Bay Shore Insurance Agency email list
How many insurance agency businesses are in Bay Shore?
Bay Shore, NY has 31 insurance agency businesses in the MapLeads maps index — 1.4% of the city's 2,165 total, with 64.5% carrying a website. Counts refresh with each index update.
Does the list separate independent insurance agencies from captive agents tied to one carrier, like State Farm or Allstate?
Both types can appear under the same insurance-agency category since Maps does not encode carrier exclusivity, but captive agencies almost always carry the carrier brand in their business name, making the two groups easy to tell apart by name.
How does Bay Shore compare with other NY cities for insurance agency?
Brooklyn leads NY with 354 insurance agency businesses; Bay Shore holds 31. Both city markets are linked below.